I recently purchased the Everlane Soft Cotton Square Cardigan as part of my spring update.
I previously owned two black cardigans, both thrifted, but one was too formal for my wardrobe and the other had a hole in the back that was irreparable due to the open weave design. I liked the idea of a cropped, slightly oversized cardigan to wear with skirts and higher waisted jeans (at this point, pretty much all of my jeans are mid or high rise).
Ethical Details: Sweater - Everlane; Top - Seamly.co via Ash & Rose; Denim - vintage, thrifted; Necklace - c/o Ember Boutique; Shoes - purchased in Austin
The VerdictColor: Washed Black
I purchased this for both the silhouette and the fabric. The thick cotton is durable and more suitable for transitional spring weather than my cashmere collection. I'm satisfied with the washed black color, sleeve length, and overall silhouette.
As expected, this item is quite oversized. I'd guessed that looking at the model, so I ordered an XS, a size down from my usual size (I also get an XS in the U-Necks). The Cotton Square Cardigan is just as expected, so I'm happy.